Cookies and Cream Popsicles

Here in Chicago, we have been having 100 degree days all week and I decided that it was just way too hot to bake.  I recently bought this Norpro Ice Pop Maker from Amazon and it seemed like the perfect time to use it.  But, hmmm…what to make first?   To figure this out, I grabbed the book Ice Pops off my bookshelf and whoa did I find lots of recipes that I want to try!  But, given my love for Oreos, the cookies and cream popsicle caught my attention immediately.  The creamy base is a no-cook, Philadelphia style ice cream made of milk and cream, no egg yolks.  Sour cream is added for richness and provides a slight tang to balance the sweetness of the rest of the pop.  Once you prepare the sweet cream, you fold in pea-sized bits of Oreo cookies to complete the mixture.  Then you just pour them into your molds, Zoku or even paper cups and let them freeze.  That’s it.  Easy peasy, right?

I made them after the kids went to bed so I could surprise them with a fun after dinner treat the next night.  Jack and Sammie absolutely loved them!  They had 2 pops each and both of them were asking to have another one.  No, I think two is plenty.  Even the baby had one, well soft of.  Alex didn’t really get it.  He ate a bit and then decided it best to smear the rest all over his face, hair, and high chair tray.  Oh Alex, I love you, but what a waste of a fantastic popsicle! 😀

Cookies and Cream Popsicles

Yield:  8 to 10 pops

14 chocolate wafer cookies, about 4 oz (125g) total weight

1/4 cup (2 oz/60g) superfine sugar

1/4 cup water (2 fl oz/60mL)

1/2 cup (4 fl oz/125mL) sour cream

1/4 cup (2 fl oz/60mL) whole milk

1 cup (8 fl oz/250mL) heavy cream

1 tsp vanilla extract

Working in a small bowl, crumble the cookies to make pieces about the size of peas.

In a bowl, stir together the sugar and 1/4 cup (2fl oz/60mL) water until the sugar dissolves.  Stir in the sour cream, milk, cream, and vanilla.  Add the crumbled chocolate cookies and stir to mix.

If using conventional pop molds, divide the mixture across the molds.  Cover and freeze until solid, at least 4 hours or up to 3 days.  If using sticks, insert them into the molds when the pops are partially frozen, after about 1 hour, then freeze until solid, at least 3 more hours.

If using an instant ice pop maker (Zoku), follow the manufacturer’s directions.

Source:  Ice Pops:  Recipes for Fresh and Flavorful Frozen Treats


I have been nominated by Mess Makes Food for the Addictive Blog Award.  Is there a better honor?  She has some yummy looking desserts on her blog to satisfy her sweet tooth.  A girl after my own heart. 😀  Thank you MissMessy for your support.

The rules are as follows:

  • Thank the person who nominated you and link them back.
  • Share a little bit about why you started blogging.
  • Copy and paste the award onto your blog.
  • Nominate up to 10 other bloggers you think are addictive enough to deserve the award.

Why did I start blogging?

There are many reasons…..

1.  I have a giant cookbook collection and I thought I should brush the dust off and actually use them. 😀  Along with all the crazy single use baking pans I have sitting around unused too.

2  Baking intimidates a lot of people.  I have a list of things I am intimidated to bake too.  But, I want to work on attacking that list, so I don’t have one anymore.  What is there to fear really, but a failed recipe?  That’s really not so bad.  It happens to me all the time.

3.  I am a mom. So, I want to make recipes that are both easy and delicious, that other moms can share with their children.

4.  And, most importantly, I really want these recipes available for Jack, Sammie and Alex to share with their children one day.

My nominees for the Addictive Blog award are:

Jessica @ The Jey of Cooking

Eva @ Eva Bakes

Joelen @ What’s Cookin’ Chicago

Lynsey @ Lynsey Lou’s

Sarah @ A Taste of Home Cooking

Leave a comment


  1. Congratulations! I liked the cookie and cream popsicles too. It sure has been hot this year.

  2. I love your cookies n cream flavour twist 😀
    These Popsicles look amazing!


  3. These look awesome, definitely making them soon!

    • Thanks Krissy! They were really good. Now I have to try to figure out what kind of popsicle to make next.

  4. Thanks for the nomination, Kim! Your blog is definitely addictive, and I know that those Popsicles would be too. Now I just need to buy a Popsicle mold!

    • You are very welcome Eva! And, thank you 😀 I really liked this popsicle set. I have had ones in the past with the plastic stick/holders, but the kids always lose them. The metal top held the sticks upright and worked great.

  5. These popsicles look so cool!

  6. Thanks for the nomination! These look SO delicious!

  7. amazing! I’m a huge fan of Cookies and Cream 🙂

  8. Uh oh might have to avoid buying an ice pop maker so that i don’t make these! They look so sinfully good 🙂

  9. 21stcenturyhousewife

     /  July 10, 2012

    What wonderful popsicles! I love cookies and cream! It made me smile to think of your baby ‘eating’ the popsicle – it reminds me of when my son (also an Alex) was little!

  10. I love love the popsicles.

  11. Cookies and Cream is one of my all-time-favorite combos. I actually enjoyed a delicious cookies-n-cream milkshake last night! I must try these soon and I know they will be a hit with my little man as well.

    Thanks for the nomiation!

  12. Abbie

     /  February 3, 2013

    We made these in our Zoku and they were delicious! For the Zoku I would recommend crumbling the cookies very fine – smaller than peas, so they fit into the mold easier. Can’t wait to try some of your other “pop” recipes 🙂

    • Thank you Abbie. So glad you liked them. Yes, definitely a good tip for the Zoku. Let me know how you like the others. I hope to post some new pop recipes soon. Well, as soon as it warms up a bit here in Chicago.

  13. claudia

     /  May 9, 2013

    can the sour cream be substituted?

  14. Angie

     /  June 15, 2013

    Did you use oreo (or other similar sandwich) cookies? Or just the plain chocolate wafer cookies for these? Thanks! They look great!

  15. Gracias, me encantan las papetas heladas!!!!
    Saludos desde ciudad de Mexico!!

  1. Food – Super Cool Popsicles for This Summer | Everything Cool
  2. Pumba, mistura aí! | Cuecas de Renda
  3. Супер мега мороженое - 33 креативных варианта | Живой фотоблог
  4. Popsicles Recipes: 101 Homemade Ice Pops - Embracing Homemaking
  5. 7 Funky Pops to Make This Summer | Shecky's
  6. Chill Out! Mouth-Watering Popsicles Are Our Fave Summer Treat | Stylust - The Official bebe Blog
  7. Chill Out! These Mouth-Watering Popsicles Are Our Fave Summer Treat | Stylust - The Official bebe Blog
  8. 33 glaces super cool à préparer vous-même pour rafraîchir votre été | Daily Geek Show
  9. 33 glaces super cool à préparer vous-même pour rafraîchir votre été | Oga Magazine
  10. Design Crush » Popsicles + Poptails ’13
  11. 50 Gourmet Twists on Classic Summer Treats |
  12. La lettre hebdo du 8 juillet 2013 |
  13. thecakebar: 36 Homemade Popsicle Recipes By Artsy…
  14. Recipes for homemade frozen treats | Roxies Blog
  15. 10 homemade popsicle recipes for summer | My Family Blog
  16. 6 recettes de popsicles pour se rafraîchir quand il fait chaud! |
  17. Cool Off: The Best Summer Popsicles Recipes | Skip To My Lou
  18. 20 Super Cool Ice creams To Prepare Yourself This Summer (Photo Gallery)
  19. Recipes: 10 Summer Popsicles | Lovie's Letter Blog
  20. Summer Popsicles Part Three: Cookies and Cream | Buttercups and Door Knobs
  21. 26 Popsicle recipes so you always have a nice desert in the house - Exquisite Girl
  22. 10 Easy Popsicle Recipes | Checks and Spots
  23. New Beginnings. | fraint
  24. 50 Popsicle Recipes - Chocolate Chocolate and More!
  25. 33 Super-Cool Popsicles To Make This Summer | DIY Beauty Corner
  26. Paletas de hielo: Fáciles y deliciosas
  27. 3 NEW Homemade Popsicles (Oreo, Nutella & Cheesecake Frozen Summer Treats) Bigger Bolder Baking 83

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

  • Just Baked

    Follow Me on Pinterest
  • Recent Posts

  • Categories

  • Archives

  • Enter your email address to follow this blog and receive notifications of new posts by email.

  • Certified Yummly

    Certified Yummly Recipes on
  • Just Baked on Foodgawker

    my foodgawker gallery
  • Just Baked on Tastespotting

    my photos on tastespotting
%d bloggers like this: